Five citizenship-by-investment programs are available in the Caribbean. They may look similar at first glance, but below the surface there are many differences. Each program naturally has its pluses and minuses. We compare them by the following criteria: the cost of acquiring second citizenship, the speed of application processing, the number of visa free destinations available with the Caribbean passport, the requirements for dependent family members, the tax benefits, the passport term of validity, the extradition treaties signed by the countries, and the available investment options.